An 2011 study conducted at the Australian National University in Canberra with rats’ reports that animals given an antidepressant for only seven days and stressed experimentally during this time, who were later given access to a high fat diet, put on significantly more weight than rats not given the antidepressant over the following months. Weight gain has been associated with treatment for depression, but it is not yet clear whether this is part of the recovery process. This evidence suggests these drugs may be exacting an unknown price.
Brave New World: Anti-depressants in the Modern Age
Anti-depressant drugs are some of the most widely prescribed drugs of any class, up there with antibiotics and cholesterol medication, and yet we don’t know how they work, or even if they work. The name "anti-" and "depressant" suggests a specificity that is not deserved.
Blog currently under construction
Blog under construction! Please stay tuned for improvements.
Tuesday, 5 July 2011
Do we want to be different?
A recent publication addressed the issue of potential personality change, by examining the willingness of young, healthy individuals to take drugs intended to enhance their own social, emotional, and cognitive traits. They found that people were much more reluctant to enhance traits believed to be more fundamental to self-identity (e.g., mood, empathy) than traits considered less fundamental to self-identity (e.g., concentration ability). These results suggest that individuals prefer not to lose their core sense of self, even if some gain was available. Treatment of depression alters this risk-benefit balance, and depressed individuals may indeed be quite willing to alter dysfunctional personality traits. Would they, however, be willing to increase their risk for gaining weight?
The bottom line
Who are you today? Are you content with your lot in life? How would you respond if someone offered you a pill that would bulk up your mood and not give you an unwanted gender re-assignment?
Antidepressant drugs are one of the most widely prescribed drugs in all categories, including treatments for pain, cholesterol and infection. It is reasonable to assume that this reflects the high rates of depression in Western Society, and indeed they are high; however, you don’t need to have clinical depression to be prescribed these drugs. GP’s are increasingly writing prescriptions for antidepressants without the time or training to diagnose depressive disorders, and rarely follow patients up. Current evidence suggests that antidepressant drugs may help in alleviating the symptoms of depression, but despite widespread use, the evidence is only considered moderately strong.
So, what do these drugs actually do to us? Will they have any effect if you don’t have depression? The short answer is yes, and it ways you may not have considered.
Research I have conducted with people with no history of clinical depression has demonstrated that antidepressant drugs, within 3 – 4 weeks, alter mood, personality and a range of physiological processes in otherwise entirely healthy people. Depending on the drug, we see either a flattening of mood (i.e., less negative and/or positive affect) or increases in positive aspects of mood. There are very few (<10) studies of this kind, and even fewer examining how these drugs may alter how people feel about themselves and effects on long term health.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)